Difficulties in implementing the right to medical care of the EAEU member States workers in the Russian Federation

Authors

  • Fatima O. Suleymanova National Research University “Higher School of Economics”, 3, Bolshoy Tryokhsvyatitelsky per., Moscow, 123022, Russian Federation

Abstract

The Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union provides for the creation of a common labor market and free movement of labor, which is impossible without a coordinated policy in the field of social relations. The attraction of foreign labor is facilitated not only by coordinated labor legislation, but also by social security, particular in the field of health protection. The need to provide guaranteed medical care to migrant workers is highlighted in many international instrument. However, citizens of the member States of the Union who are temporarily staying in the Russian Federation often face uncertainty about their legal status. The article analyzes the Russian legislation in the field of medical care to foreign citizens for compliance with the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union. Contradictions of the current legislation and law enforcement practice are revealed. In particular, the rules that provide for registration of both voluntary medical insurance policies (provided for temporarily staying foreign citizens) and mandatory medical insurance policies (provided for by the Treaty) do not facilitate the stay of the Eurasian Economic Union workers in comparison with citizens from other countries, but, on the contrary, involve additional procedures and expenses. It also does not correspond to the Treaty provisions a deprivation of guaranteed medical care for workers under civil law contracts and family members of migrant workers. The current judicial practice also does not contribute to the implementation of rights guaranteed by the Treaty. The elimination of these contradictions can help protect the rights of migrant workers, attract foreign labor, and create a common labor market within the Eurasian Economic Union countries.

Keywords:

medical care, migrant worker, Eurasian Economic Union, compulsory medical insurance, voluntary medical insurance

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография

Иванова, Наталья С., Варшавер, Евгений А. 2018. «Особенности правового положения трудовых мигрантов из ЕАЭС и прочих стран СНГ в России: сравнительный анализ.» Миграционное право 3: 3–8; 4: 9–16.

Капустин, Анатолий Я. 2015. «Право Евразийского экономического союза: международно-правовой дискурс.» Журнал российского права 11: 59–69.

Лушникова, Марина В., Раманкулов, Кубанычбек С., Томашевский, Кирилл Л. (ред.) 2018. Евразийское трудовое право. Учебник. Москва: Проспект.

Миронова, Тамара К. 2018. Правовое регулирование бесплатного оказания медицинской помощи. Учебное пособие. Москва: Юстиц Информ.

Нечаев, Сергей В. 2010. «Международные стандарты права на охрану здоровья.» Вестник Ярославского государственного университета им. П. Г. Демидова. Серия «Гуманитарные науки» 4 (14): 56–59.

Серебрякова, Елена А., Ситникова, Елена Г. 2017. Трудовой договор с иностранцем: от заключения до прекращения. Вып. 17. Москва: Редакция «Российской газеты».

Хохлов, Евгений Б., Сыченко, Елена В. (ред.) 2019. Правовое регулирование социально-трудовых отношений с иностранными гражданами: междисциплинарный подход. Москва: Юстицинформ.


References

Ivanova, Natal’ya S., Varshaver Evgeniy A. 2018. “Peculiarities of the Legal Status of Labor Migrants from the EAEU and other CIS Member States in Russia: a Comparative Analysis (Beginning).” Migratsionnoe pravo 3: 3–8; 4: 9–16. (In Russian)

Kapustin Anatoly Ya. 2015. “Law of the Eurasian economic Union: international legal discourse.” Journal of Russian Law 11: 59–69. (In Russian)

Khokhlov, Evgeny B., Sychenko, Elena V. (eds) 2019. Legal regulation of social and labor relations with foreign citizens: an interdisciplinary approach. Moscow, Iustitsinform. (In Russian)

Lushnikova, Marina V., Ramankulov, Kubanychbek, S., Tomashevsky, Kirill L. (eds) 2018. Eurasian labor law. Textbook. Moscow, Prospekt. (In Russian)

Mironova, Tamara K. 2018. Legal regulation of the provision of free medical care: a training manual. Moscow, Iustits Inform. (In Russian)

Nechaev, Sergey V. 2010. “International standards of the right to health protection.” Vestnik Yaroslavskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. P. G. Demidova. Series “Gumanitarnye nauki” 4 (14): 56–59. (In Russian)

Serebryakova, Elena A., Sitnikova, Elena G. 2017. Labor contract with a foreigner: from conclusion to termination. Iss. 17. Moscow, Redaktsiia “Rossiiskoi gazety”. (In Russian)

Published

2021-02-26

How to Cite

Suleymanova, F. O. (2021). Difficulties in implementing the right to medical care of the EAEU member States workers in the Russian Federation. Russian Journal of Labour & Law, 11, 357–367. Retrieved from https://rjll.spbu.ru/article/view/12020

Issue

Section

Articles