Remuneration of teachers in Russia: problem statement

Authors

  • Fatima K. Nogaylieva St Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation
  • Marina V. Filippova St Petersburg State University, 7–9, Universitetskaya nab., St Petersburg, 199034, Russian Federation

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu32.2024.105

Abstract

The subject of the study is two main models according to which the current systems of remuneration of teachers of general education organizations in Russia are built. The analysis of the norms revealed that federal legislation refers the issues of establishing wage systems to the competence of educational organizations. At the same time, there are no mandatory regulatory requirements for the salary amount, as well as for the composition and amount of surcharges and allowances of teachers as such. At the federal level, only a number of guarantees have been established to ensure the minimum wage for teachers, while the choice of specific mechanisms for its implementation is given to the level of subjects of the Russian Federation, local governments, educational organizations. The study of regional and municipal regulatory
legal acts has shown that the absence in the salary system of centralized regulatory consolidation of restrictions on the structure of the salary fund at school, if many recommendations on the size and proportion of salaries are not followed, leads to a blurring of the salary structure, a large and unjustified regional differentiation of the base salary and its low level. A large gap in the amount of rates independently set in the subjects of the Russian Federation leads to different pay for work of equal value, which violates one of the basic principles of labor law — equal pay for work of equal value, and puts the material (and, as a consequence, social) position of teachers dependent not on the quality and quantity of their work, it depends on the level of economic development of the region. The article criticizes the idea of introducing a single federal salary as a measure aimed at increasing the total salary of a teacher. Among the possible ways to solve the problems, the authors point to the need to develop a set of federal recommendations: on the minimum share of the salary of teaching staff in the total amount of wages; on the grounds of establishing an increasing coefficient to the salary; on the grounds of establishing compensatory payments for the performance of work that goes beyond the labor function of the teacher; on the grounds of establishing incentive payments, in particular to reflect in the salary indicators the quality and effectiveness of pedagogical work.

Keywords:

remuneration system, educational organization, teaching staff, official salary, rate, allowances, compensation payments

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
 

References

Библиография

Абанкина, Ирина В., Анна А. Вавилова, Павел В. Деркачев, Кирилл В. Зиньковский, Иван А. Кравченко и Надежда Е. Суркова. 2021. «Оплата труда педагогов: как изменить ситуацию к лучшему?» Современная аналитика образования 7 (56): 1–68.

Геращенко, Ирина П., Юлия В. Марус и Елена В. Коваленко. 2021. «Региональная дифференциация оплаты труда учителей: проблемы, тенденции и перспективы.» Фундаментальные исследования 11: 56–60.

Головчин, Максим А. 2021. «Реализация принципа достойной оплаты труда в российском образовании: экономико-статистическое исследование.» Вопросы статистики 28 (3): 15–30.

Городкова, Светлана А., Марина И. Дроздова, Наталья В. Медведева и Анна А. Алетдинова. 2022. «Особенности оплаты труда педагогических работников как многомерного объекта, основанного на факторах рационализации.» Baikal Research Journal 13 (3).

Заир-Бек, Сергей И., Татьяна А. Мерцалова и Константин М. Анчиков. 2020. «Кадры школьного образования: возможности и дефициты.» Мониторинг экономики образования. Вып. 18. Национальный исследовательский университет «Высшая школа экономики». URL: https://clck.ru/SCjzk (дата обращения: 14.06.2023).

Конюкова, Наталья И. 2020. «Создание единой системы оплаты труда в общем образовании в контексте экономической безопасности.» Развитие территорий 3 (21): 9–12.

Синица, Арсений Л. 2019. «Влияние формы собственности образовательной организации на заработную плату педагогических работников.» Экономическая наука современной России 2: 103–114.

Ястребова, Ольга К., Андрей А. Лазарев и Дарья П. Зубринская. 2021. «На счет педагога. Целевые ориентиры и ограничения в разных системах оплаты труда.» Образовательная политика. 2 (86): 96–106.

References

Abankina, Irina М., Anna А. Vavilova, Pavel V. Derkachev, Kirill V. Zinkovsky, Ivan A. Kravchenko and Nadezhda E. Surkova. 2021. “Payment for teachers: how to change the situation for the better?” Sovremennaia analitika obrazovaniia 7 (56): 1–68. (In Russian)

Gerashchenko, Irina P., Yulia V. Marus and Elena V. Kovalenko. 2021. “Regional differentiation of teacher’ remuneration: Problems, trends and prospects.” Fundamental’nye issledovaniia 11: 56–60. (In Russian)

Golovchin, Maxim A. 2021. “Implementation of the Principle of Decent Wages in Russian Education: Economic and Statistical Study.” Voprosy statistiki 28 (3): 15–30. (In Russian)

Gorodkova Svetlana A., Marina I. Drozdova, Natalia V. Medvedeva and Anna A. Aletdinova. 2022. “Nuances of Remuneration of Pedagogical Workers as a Multidimensional Object, Based on Rationalization Factors.” Baikal Research Journal 13 (3). (In Russian)

Konyukova, Natalia I. 2020. “Creation of unified system of wage in general education in context of economic security.” Razvitie territorii 3 (21): 9–12. (In Russian)

Sinitsa, Arseny L. 2019. “The Influence of the Ownership Form of the Educational Organization on the Salary of Pedagogical Employees.” Ekonomicheskaia nauka sovremennoi Rossii 2: 103–114. (In Russian)

Yastrebova, Olga K., Andrey A. Lazarev and Daria P. Zubrinskaya. 2021. “Teacher’s pay: Targets and limitations in the different pay systems.” Obrazovatel’naia politika 2 (86): 96–106. (In Russian)

Zair-Bek, Sergey I., Tatiana A. Mertsalova and Konstantin M. Anchikov. 2020. “School education personnel: Opportunities and deficits.” Monitoring ekonomiki obrazovaniya. Iss. 18. HSE University. Available at: https://clck.ru/SCjzk (accessed: 14.06.2023). (In Russian)

Published

2024-03-16

How to Cite

Nogaylieva, F. K., & Filippova, M. V. (2024). Remuneration of teachers in Russia: problem statement. Russian Journal of Labour & Law, 14, 77–93. https://doi.org/10.21638/spbu32.2024.105

Issue

Section

Educational law and labor: past, present and future