Pandemic and labour law: the reaction of Russian and Italian authorities

Authors

Abstract

The authors consider the changes in Russian and Italian labour law adopted in connection with the coronavirus pandemic. The measures of workers’ support during the forced suspension of business activities is considered in the part 1, the regulation of remote work — in the
part 2. Analysis of the measures taken by the Russian and Italian authorities in connection with the suspension of business activities showed that it was possible to overcome the emergency situation not only by placing the whole responsibility on the employer as it was done
in Russia. The Italian experience of compensating a part of the wages not received due to the organization’s suspension from the State Wage Fund seems to be particularly valuable. The authors conclude that the Russian authorities, in contrast to the Italian ones, failed to ensure timely adoption of regulations for temporary transition to remote work and for the mixed form of work. The draft amendments to the chapter of the Russian Labour Code on remote work simplifies the procedure for concluding an agreement and excludes the norm on the possibility of establishing grounds for termination of an employment contract in the contract itself, but does not imply any changes to the norms on occupational safety of such employees. The latter, in our opinion, is a serious omission. We believe that the establishment of the employer’s obligations to provide the equipment and to monitor the employee’s compliance with the occupational safety rules, as fixed in the Italian norms on remote work, better protects workers’ interests and rights.

Keywords:

COVID-19, remote work, unemployment, labour law, digitalization

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография

Ахмеджанова, Рузана. 2020. Счет пошел на триллионы: сколько российский бизнес потеряет из-за пандемии. 28.03.2020. URL: https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/396055-schet-poshel-na-trilliony-skolkorossiyskiy-biznes-poteryaet-iz-za-pandemii (дата обращения: 20.06.2020).

Бикметов, Рустам. 2013. «Особенности обеспечения требований охраны труда дистанционных работников. Возможные противоречия в обеспечении социальной защиты дистанционных работников, пострадавших в результате травмы на производстве и профзаболеваний.» Трудовое право в России и за рубежом 3.

Васильева, Юлия, Шуралева, Светлана, Браун, Елена. 2016. Правовое регулирование дистанционной работы: проблемы теории и практики. Пермь, Пермский государственный национальный исследовательский университет.

Парягина, Ольга, Барнакова, Елена. 2017. «Дистанционный труд: особенности и проблемы правового регулирования.» ГлаголЪ правосудия. 2: 3–6.

Стребкова, Анна. 2020. «Дистанционный труд: развитие, проблемы, перспективы.» Вопросы российской юстиции 7: 374–381.

Ales, Edoardo. 2020. “Quale welfare ai tempi della Pandemia.” Rivista di Diritto della Sicurezza Sociale 2: 429–438.

Alessi, Cristina, Vallauri, Maria Luisa. 2020. “Il lavoro agile alla prova del Covid-19”. Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori. Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma: Ediesse: 135.

Bellavista, Alessandro. 2020. “Normativa emergenziale e diritti fondamentali.” Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori.

Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma: Ediesse: 37–50.

Gaglione, Chiara, Purificato, Ilaria, Rymkevich, Olga. 2020. “COVID-19 and Labour Law: Italy.” Italian Labour Law e-Journal 1 (13). URL: https://illej.unibo.it/article/view/10793 (дата обращения: 20.06.2020).

Pallante, Francesco. “Il diritto costitutionale e l’emergenza Covid-19.” Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori. Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma: Ediesse: 21–22.

Risak, Martin. 2020. “COVID-19 and Labour Law: Austria.” Italian Labour Law e-Journal 1 (13). URL: https://illej.unibo.it/article/view/10793 (дата обращения: 20.06.2020).

Timellini, Caterina. 2020. “Disconnection: A Right in a Phase of Progressive Definition.” New Forms of Employment: Current Problems and Future Challenges. Eds J. Wratny, A. Ludera-Ruszel. Wiesbaden: Springer Nature: 119–136.

Zoppoli, Lorenzo, Monda, Pasquale. 2020. “Innovazioni tecnologiche e lavoro nelle pubbliche amministrazioni”. Diritto delle Relazioni Industriali. (В печати.)


References

Akhmedzhanova, Ruzanа. 2020. The account went to trillions: how much Russian business will lose because of the pandemic. 28.03.2020. Available at: https://www.forbes.ru/biznes/396055-schet-poshel-na-trilliony-skolko-rossiyskiy-biznes-poteryaet-iz-za-pandemii (accessed: 20.06.2020). (In Russian)

Ales, Eduardo. 2020. “Quale welfare ai tempi della Pandemia.” Rivista di Diritto della Sicurezza Sociale 2: 429–438.

Alessi, Cristina, Vallauri, Maria Luisa. 2020. “Il lavoro agile alla prova del Covid-19.” Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori. Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma, Ediesse: 135.

Bellavista, Alessandro. 2020. “Normativa emergenziale e diritti fondamentali.” Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori. Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma, Ediesse: 37–50.

Bikmetov, Rustam. 2013. “Peculiarities of Ensuring Labor Safety Requirements of Remote Workers. Possible contradictions in provision of social protection of remote workers injured as a result of injury at work and occupational diseases.” Trudovoe pravo v Rossii i za rubezhom 3 (In Russian)

Gaglione, Chiara, Purificato, Ilaria, Rymkevich, Olga. “COVID-19 and Labour Law: Italy.” Italian Labour Law e-Journal 1 (13). Available at: https://illej.unibo.it/article/view/10793 (accessed: 20.06.2020).

Pallante, Francesco. “Il diritto costitutionale e l’emergenza Covid-19.” Covid-19 e diritti dei lavoratori. Eds O. Bonardi, U. Carabelli, M. D’Onghia, L. Zoppoli. Roma, Ediesse: 21–22.

Paryagina, Olga, Barnakova, Elena. 2017. “Remote work: features and problems of legal regulation.” Glagol pravosudia 2: 3–6. (In Russian)

Risak, Martin. 2020. “COVID-19 and Labour Law: Austria.” Italian Labour Law e-Journal 1 (13). Available at: https://illej.unibo.it/article/view/10793 (accessed: 20.06.2020).

Strebkova, Anna. 2020. “Remote work: development, problems, prospects.” Voprosy rossiiskoi iustitsii 7: 374–381. (In Russian)

Timellini, Caterina. “Disconnection: A Right in a Phase of Progressive Definition.” New Forms of Employment: Current Problems and Future Challenges. Eds J. Wratny, A. Ludera-Ruszel. Wiesbaden, Springer Nature: 119–136.

Vasilyeva, Yulia, Shuraleva, Svetlana, Brown Elena. 2016. Legal regulation of remote work: problems of theory and practice. Perm, Perm State University. (In Russian)

Zoppoli, Lorenzo, Monda, Pasquale. 2020. “Innovazioni tecnologiche e lavoro nelle pubbliche amministrazioni.” Diritto delle Relazioni Industriali. (In press.)

Published

2021-02-26

How to Cite

Menegatti, E., & Sychenko, E. V. (2021). Pandemic and labour law: the reaction of Russian and Italian authorities. Russian Journal of Labour & Law, 11, 56–71. Retrieved from https://rjll.spbu.ru/article/view/11994

Issue

Section

Articles