Social Protection beyond the Employment Contract: the role played by the European Court of Justice

Authors

  • Emanuele Menegatti University of Bologna, 33, via Zamboni, Bologna, 40126, Italy

Abstract

The number of non-standard and precarious work arrangements, not falling within the domain of labour law, most recently those prompted by new techonologies (crowdworking, platform work, etc), has been sharply increasing across the member states of the European Union over the last twenty years or so. As this article will argue, the Court of Justice of the European Union, in shaping the scope of EU labour law, has been looking beyond the traditional categories in order to provide some core employment and social rights to atypical work arrangements. This has been done by building a common EU concept of worker, broader than that of ‘employee’ endorsed by national jurisdictions, and by applying it to an increasing body of EU social legislation. In particular, the Court of Justice elaboration has started from the field of the free movement of workers, and then moved to employment protection Directives and eventually to the so-called labour exception to antitrust law. Beyond the extension of the scope of employment and social protection lies a purposive method of interpretation of EU primary and secondary law used by the Court of Justice, facilitated by the new role which the CFREU gained with the Lisbon Treaty and a parallel increasing relevance acquired by the EU social sphere.

Keywords:

EU law, concept of worker, platform worker, labour law, EU directives, interpretation

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Библиография/References

Barnard, Catherin. 2012. EU Employment Law. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Countouris, Nicola. 2017. “The concept of ‘Worker’ in European Labour Law: Fragmentation, Autonomy and Scope” Industrial Law Journal 47 (2): 192–225.

Countouris, Nicola. 2011. “The Employment Relationship: A Comparative Analysis of National Judicial Approaches”. The Employment Relationship: A Comparative Overview, ed. G. Casale, 30–58.

Deakin, Simon, Wilkinson, Frank. 2005. The Law of the Labour Market: Industrialization, Employment and Legal Evolution. Oxford, Oxford University Press.

Nogler, Luca. 2010. “Rethinking the Lawrie-Blum Doctrine of Subordination: A Critical Analysis Prompted by Recent Developments in Italian Employment Law”. International Journal of Comparative Labour Law and Industrial Relations 26 (1): 83–102.

Risak, Martin, Dullinger, Thomas. 2018. The concept of ‘worker’ in EU law: Status quo and potential for change. ETUI Research Paper-Report 140.

Van Peijpe, Taco. 2012. “EU Limits for the Personal Scope of Employment Law”, European Labour Law Journal 3 (1): 35–53.

Perulli, Adalberto. 2011. “Subordinate, Autonomous and Economically Dependent Work: A Comparative Analysis of Selected European Countries”. Ed. by Giuseppe Casale. A Comparative Overview: 130–165.

Published

2022-04-23

How to Cite

Menegatti, E. (2022). Social Protection beyond the Employment Contract: the role played by the European Court of Justice. Russian Journal of Labour & Law, 10, 275–285. Retrieved from https://rjll.spbu.ru/article/view/13409

Issue

Section

Международное и зарубежное социальное право